New York Metropolitans in 1886

Steve Behel
Steve Brady
Peter Connell
Joe Crotty
Ed Cushman
Jim Donahue
Tom Forster
Elmer Foster
Frank Hankinson
Bill Holbert
Jack Lynch
Fred Mauer
Al Mays
Tom McLaughlin
John Meister
Candy Nelson
Dave Orr
Charlie Reipschlager
Chief Roseman
John Shaffer
Chief Zimmer